中文
Environmental trends in materials and tougher vehicle engineering standards have driven several rounds of change in air-conditioning compressor oil requirements over the past two decades or so.
Mineral oil was the mainstream air-conditioning compressor lubricant until the early 1990s, because it was miscible with R-12 refrigerant. Once R-12 was phased out for depleting the ozone layer, mineral oil could not mix with the more environmentally friendly R-134a and went out with it. In 1994 R-134a became the mainstream refrigerant in US mobile air-conditioning systems, and polyalkylene glycol (PAG) oil rose alongside it.
Because mineral oil and PAG oil cannot be mixed, a transitional oil was needed, and ester oil filled that role. When R-12 vehicles were converted to R-134a, the mineral oil left in the system was incompatible with R-134a, and PAG oil could not simply be added because it would clash with the residual mineral oil, so ester oil was used to bridge the change. At first it was recommended only for those conversions.
Three PAG viscosities dominate the R-134a era: PAG 46 is the most commonly used, PAG 100 is also widespread, and PAG 150 is less common but was still required by certain compressors on some models from the 1990s into the early 2000s.
After roughly two decades of dominance in the US market, R-134a began to give way for environmental reasons as well. R-134a does not deplete the ozone layer, but its global warming potential (GWP) is high, so R-1234yf was developed with excellent cooling performance and a low GWP. Just as the phase-out of R-12 gave rise to ester and PAG oils, R-1234yf brought new compressor oil requirements: automakers now call for more varied and more specific lubricant formulations. Industry observers note that R-1234yf requires dedicated lubricants, that each automaker has its own proprietary formulation, and that servicing a yf vehicle means using the specified oil.
One industry training manager said that in the parts rooms of the shops he visits, the air-conditioning shelf often holds as many as 25 different bottles of refrigerant oil, because every automaker specifies a different lubricant for its systems.
Other Compressor Oils on the Market
PAG oils dominate, but there are important exceptions. Polyalphaolefin (PAO) oils can replace some PAG oils and are favoured because, unlike other refrigeration oils, they do not absorb moisture from the air. For hybrids with electrically driven compressors, polyol ester (POE) oil is not only recommended but in many cases mandatory.
Using PAG oil in a hybrid can damage the vehicle and endanger the technician, because the wrong compressor lubricant carries a risk of electric shock. There are cases where a technician added ordinary PAG oil to a hybrid and ended up replacing the entire air-conditioning system: when the system detects a degree of conductive path inside the compressor housing, it illuminates a warning and shuts the air conditioning down.
The Myth of Universal Oil
Many suppliers market a universal compressor oil, claiming it suits any vehicle (hybrids excepted) and both R-12 and R-134a. Experts say the only universal thing about it is the risk it creates. Warranty data from one component supplier showed that a quarter of vehicle claims came from shops that had not used the correct PAG oil for the compressor. Universal or mixed oils inevitably lead to seizure and failure: universal products are typically PAO or mineral oils of a different viscosity from synthetic PAG, PAO has poor miscibility with PAG oil, R-134a and R-1234yf, lubrication suffers and wear increases, and the viscosity mismatch thins the oil film between cylinder bore and piston, causing seizure or a shortened compressor life.
Ignoring the manufacturer's recommendation is where trouble starts. Just as you would not put 10W-30 in an engine specified for 0W-20, an air-conditioning system must get the specified oil, not whatever happens to be on the shelf.
